ABB Stock Market Trading

I've been playing around with one of my old trading plans for the last couple of weeks and pulled out my tracking chart for ABB. They happen to be a power and automation company (robots and power converters) but that really has no bearing on why I was following them as I had to look them up in order to find out what they really were.

Basically I feel that the charts tell the whole story and the price reflects that story. The issue I have always had with fundamental or value investing is that you must try to discern the story ahead of time. While some of the company's fundamental data will reflect it's overall health, it does not indicate what will happen tomorrow and certainly does not predict the future price. Although some make out well with this style of investing I just don't have the patience to sit on something long enough to find out that I was wrong in my assumptions.

If you look at Apple (AAPL), everyone thought that with the demise of Steve Jobs, Apple stock would drop. While it did for a short period, it certainly was only a blip in the price as it quickly surpassed the price that it had reached during Steve's reign. I sometimes give my butt a little kick for not buying it when I first looked at it, around $85. Meanwhile, it is not one of the stocks that I follow for the purpose of trading, the price is too high for my style of trading and account size.

Back to ABB.

This has been one of my worst performing selections so I figured what better one to choose for setting up my spreadsheet to re-run the old numbers through my improved simplified plan. Performance is relative to the plan implemented afterall. Of course I expected an overall loss based on the look of the historical chart and my previous simplified plan. Something like a $9.50 loss per share over a 10 year period while only trading long and running every setup. With a win rate of 37.5%, no wonder.

In almost all of my studies, trading with the trend has a better win rate. Simple trend determination just using a couple of simple moving averages and their cross overs. It doesn't need to be complicated as these are not trade indicators, just a quick guide to remove the subjective decision of whether or not a trend is up or down.

Switching to simple trend following, this loss drops to $2 per share with a 54.6% win rate.

Adding more trades using varied or staged entry targets bumps the total returns to $3.50 per share.

Part of the higher profitability of this version of the plan has to do with taking more trades overall with the idea that if the first trade stops out for a loss, the remaining individual trades based on the same trigger may not. This creates a greater edge, 14% greater as the new win rate is 68.6%. There are 72% more trades so in order to better compare them, the average return per trade was a $0.17 loss vs an $0.18 profit per trade.

Next, using the same plan but implementing a half trade trailing profit stop. A Virtual Trailing Stop Order (VTSO) will work well in this particular application. This could be applied a few ways but I would choose to enter the trades using the same method as above with the VTSO applied to half of the total trade. If the price proceeds to run up past the initial profit target, the VTSO will capture more profits than otherwise might be had. The very worst case once the initial profit target is hit is that the remaining half of the trade could stop out at break even, it will never turn into a loss at that point. Of course in all cases where the initial target is not hit, the entire trade stops out for a loss. The upside potential is greater than the downside which makes this style of trade worth the added complexity.

VTSO partial profit stop, $8.13 per share profit with the same win rate of 68.6%. Same trades, just managed differently.

Seeing as the stock started out around $5 when this plan starts, the overall Return On Investment... if you want to call this an investment... is over 162%. That, over 10 years, is certainly worth the effort.

It is worth mentioning that all of my results are based on nice even price numbers, 25, 50 cent increment or $1 depending upon the value of the stock at the time of the trade. Using the VTSO provides that the profit may be at a price relative to the penny increment moves of the price but will be above break even in all cases when the initial target is attained. This puts the real VTSO at a non-zero profit value almost immediately. Entries and exits are subject to a certain amount of slippage and variations in opening prices can affect the entries, although this, like the VTSO, would be in my favour as I use limit orders to enter and exit at targets. The real odd factor might be the overnight gap in price. Those occur but can go in either direction so they are tough to try factor in ahead of time. I figure that the odds are, while trading with a trend, better that the gap be in my favour but will concede a 50/50 shot at getting them right.

Next up, the short sell. This post is already too long.

Jeff.